Methodology

Our SEO methodology: how evidence becomes prioritized work

Our SEO methodology is how WindSpeedSEO decides what matters, described in enough detail that you can disagree with it. Prioritization you cannot inspect is just an opinion with a number attached.

How a finding earns its place Evidence rules first, then scoring, then verification, then honest attribution. A flow: an observation must pass the evidence rules (source ordering, first-party data before third-party estimates); it is scored on change magnitude, commercial relevance, evidence strength and expected effort; each change is checked before it is marked done; every claim must meet the attribution standard.
Observation
Something changed or an opportunity appears
Evidence rules first-party data before estimates
Scored on four axes
Change magnitude
Commercial relevance
Evidence strength
Expected effort
Before it reaches you
Verification standard each change checked first
Attribution standard only supported claims

Evidence rules

Every finding WindSpeedSEO raises must trace to an observable source. In practice that means one of five things:

  • First-party Google data. Search Console for search performance, Analytics 4 for behavior. Treated as the primary record.
  • Platform-managed performance data. PageSpeed for lab measurement, CrUX for real-user field data where Google reports it.
  • Public observation. What a search engine or AI crawler can see when it visits your site: status codes, canonicals, robots.txt rules, robots directives, sitemaps, markup, internal links.
  • Third-party SEO data. Keyword, SERP, competitor and backlink data from established data providers, reported as estimates rather than as facts.
  • Repeatable AI-visibility measurement. A fixed query set run on a schedule, reported as frequency across runs.

Anything that cannot be traced to one of those is context or opinion, and is labeled as such.

Source ordering: the most reliable evidence first

Sources are used in a deliberate order: your own Google Search Console and Analytics 4 data first, then what can be observed directly on your site, then third-party SEO data, with AI analysis applied where it genuinely improves the answer.

This has a practical consequence for you: recommendations rest on the strongest evidence available, and third-party estimates add context without overriding what Google reports for your own site.

How findings are scored

Four axes, applied to every candidate finding.

Change magnitude

How large the movement is relative to that page or query’s own normal variance — not relative to the site as a whole.

Commercial relevance

What the affected pages and queries are worth, drawn from analytics behavior and conversion data where it is configured.

Evidence strength

How many independent signals agree. A decline confirmed by position, clicks and competitor movement outranks one visible in a single metric.

Expected effort

An effort estimate used to sequence the work, so quick, valuable fixes are not stuck behind large projects. It is never billed as hours.

Findings that are large, commercially relevant, well-evidenced and tractable rise to the top. Everything else stays visible and stays below.

One ordering rule overrides the score: anything preventing a commercially valuable page from being indexed outranks anything that merely degrades how well it competes. A page that cannot appear at all is not competing.

Verification standard

Each change is checked before it is marked done, against questions with objective answers: is the change live, does the URL return the expected status, is the canonical correct, is the content indexable, did the redirect chain collapse to a single hop, does the published article exist at the expected address.

AI may help interpret an ambiguous requirement or explain how to fix a finding. It is never what marks a change as done; where a requirement cannot be checked automatically, a person checks it.

Only checked work is reported to you as completed, and its outcome is measured against the following period.

Attribution standard

Observation and causation are reported separately. WindSpeedSEO will state what changed, by how much and on which pages. It will claim that a specific change caused a specific result only where the timing and the evidence support it, and it will say when a change is too recent to evaluate.

Seasonality, competitor activity and broad algorithmic movement are named as context — including in months where naming them makes the results look worse.

What our SEO methodology will not do

  • Guarantee rankings, traffic or revenue.
  • Fabricate or adjust recorded keyword volume or difficulty values.
  • Present a third-party provider estimate as a measured fact.
  • Report unverified work as complete.
  • Present the same generic recommendation regardless of what the evidence shows.

Return to the WindSpeedSEO overview, or see the methodology in operation in how WindSpeedSEO works.

See the methodology applied to your website

The same evidence rules and prioritization model run on both plans.